Difference between revisions of "User:Yvand/FreJND"
From CrossWire Bible Society
m (add website url) |
m (update resolved/fixed issues) |
||
(One intermediate revision by the same user not shown) | |||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
− | New website : [https://frejnd.yapper.fr] | + | New website : [https://frejnd.yapper.fr frejnd.yapper.fr] |
+ | |||
+ | |||
+ | ==== Suggestions, ideas for improvement ==== | ||
+ | |||
+ | * References to notes, reported by [[User:Yvand|Yvand]] | ||
+ | :Some notes refer to other notes (in another passage), and so uses <nowiki>*</nowiki> (or <nowiki>**</nowiki> etc.) to refer to a particular notes in a verse. | ||
+ | :Two examples have been noticed, see the note ''e'' in [http://koocotte.org/darby/html/Judg.html#Judg.13.19 Judg.13.19] and in the note in [http://koocotte.org/darby/html/1Chr.html#1Chr.26.18 1Chr.26.18] (<nowiki>**</nowiki> should be replaced by the given note attribute). | ||
+ | :I guess these two particular cases should be corrected manually. | ||
+ | * Move spacing tags from Psalm headers to verse 1 in Psalms, suggested by [[User:Yvand|Yvand]] | ||
+ | :As in the paper version, my opinion is that spacing tags shouldn't be in Psalms headers but at the beginning of verse 1. | ||
+ | :See for example [http://koocotte.org/darby/html/Ps.html#Ps.3 Ps.3], [http://koocotte.org/darby/html/Ps.html#Ps.9 Ps.9], [http://koocotte.org/darby/html/Ps.html#Ps.16 Ps.16] etc. | ||
+ | * Keep the notes in book and chapter titles, suggested by [[User:Yvand|Yvand]] | ||
+ | :Currently notes in book titles ([http://koocotte.org/darby/html/Song.html Song], [http://koocotte.org/darby/html/Rev.html Rev] are concerned) are moved to a paragraph foregoing the chapter content. | ||
+ | ::Those two notes do not preview correctly in Xiphos. [[User:David Haslam|David Haslam]] | ||
+ | :As well, notes in chapter titles ([http://koocotte.org/darby/html/Ps.html#Ps.25 Ps.25], [http://koocotte.org/darby/html/Ps.html#Ps.34 Ps.34], [http://koocotte.org/darby/html/Ps.html#Ps.37 Ps.37], [http://koocotte.org/darby/html/Ps.html#Ps.111 Ps.111], [http://koocotte.org/darby/html/Ps.html#Ps.112 Ps.112], [http://koocotte.org/darby/html/Ps.html#Ps.119 Ps.119], [http://koocotte.org/darby/html/Ps.html#Ps.145 Ps.145], [http://koocotte.org/darby/html/Lam.html#Lam.1 Lam.1] are concerned) are also moved at the beginning of a paragraph below. | ||
+ | ::The notes in those Psalm titles preview OK in Xiphos, but the note in Lam 1 does not. [[User:David Haslam|David Haslam]] | ||
==== Resolved issues ==== | ==== Resolved issues ==== | ||
+ | |||
+ | * Wrong note numbering when both standard notes and references notes are present, reported by [[User:Yvand|Yvand]] | ||
+ | :This issue concerns only some notes in the NT. It appears if a verse mixes standard notes and crossReference notes. | ||
+ | :See [http://koocotte.org/darby/html/Matt.html#Matt.4.10 Matt.4.10] [http://koocotte.org/darby/html/Heb.html#Heb.3.11 Heb.3.11] for instance. | ||
+ | :Skc> Hard to fix, as crossReferences are parsed first and then standard notes | ||
+ | * Missing paragraph breaks after (some) clusters/stars , reported by [[User:Yvand|Yvand]] | ||
+ | :The presence of a cluster in the source involves a new paragraph. But it doesn't work if the cluster does not follow a paragraph of notes. | ||
+ | :Examples for Clustermoyen can be found in [http://koocotte.org/darby/html/Gen.html#Gen.11.27 Gen.11.27], [http://koocotte.org/darby/html/Gen.html#Gen.25.12 Gen.25.12]. | ||
+ | :Examples for Clustersecondaire can be found in the Psalms, for instance [http://koocotte.org/darby/html/Ps.html#Ps.3.7 Ps.3.7], [http://koocotte.org/darby/html/Ps.html#Ps.4.2 Ps.4.2], [http://koocotte.org/darby/html/Ps.html#Ps.5.3 Ps.5.3], [http://koocotte.org/darby/html/Ps.html#Ps.27 Ps.27], [http://koocotte.org/darby/html/Ps.html#Ps.14.1 Ps.14.1]. | ||
+ | * Missing paragraph break in [http://koocotte.org/darby/html/1John.html#1John.2.13 1John.2.13] (twice) and in [http://koocotte.org/darby/html/1John.html#1John.2.14 1John.2.14] | ||
+ | * Wrong note ID in the titles of the books [http://koocotte.org/darby/html/Song.html Song] and [http://koocotte.org/darby/html/Rev.html Rev], reported by [[User:Yvand|Yvand]] | ||
+ | :Skc> Still exists? Yes! [[User:David Haslam|David Haslam]] | ||
+ | :Yvand> Yes, the osisRef and osisID attributes still contains the osisID of the previous book (for example for the note in Rev : osisRef="Jude.1.0" osisID="Jude.1.0_1" but n="a") | ||
+ | :Yvand> (I do not know what is best but in my opinion, the alphabetic numeration of notes should start at the beginning of a chapter. So if a note is present in the booktitle (only 2 cases) it shouldn't start the numeration of the chapter. But what value should we use for the n attribute? x? *?) | ||
+ | * Same notes with different ''n'' attributes, reported by [[User:Yvand|Yvand]] | ||
+ | :The issue seems to concern only two verses, these verses contain notes which should use the same ''n'' attribute! | ||
+ | :The note ''d'' in [http://koocotte.org/darby/html/Zech.html#Zech.5.3 Zech.5.3] must be ''c'' ; as well the note ''i'' in [http://koocotte.org/darby/html/Isa.html#Isa.24.16 Isa.24.16] must be ''h''. | ||
+ | :This is due to a limitation in darbywork.pl which doesn't allow same duplicate note <nowiki>**</nowiki> or <nowiki>***</nowiki>, so darby.patch forces to create a new note. | ||
+ | * Use <code>id</code> attribute instead of <code>name</code> attribute in html files, add <code>href</code> attribute in <code>a</code> tags, suggested by [[User:Yvand|Yvand]] | ||
+ | :A patch (for <code>osis2html.xslt</code>) has been send to the developper. | ||
+ | * Use range verses in osisRef, for continuous verses, suggested by [[User:Yvand|Yvand]] | ||
+ | :For example <code><reference osisRef="Exod.22.26">Exode 22:26</reference>-27</code> should be replaced by <code><reference osisRef="Exod.22.26-27">Exode 22:26-27</reference></code> in [http://koocotte.org/darby/html/Job.html#Job.24.9 Job.24.9 (note)]. According to the OSIS Manual, this syntax is valid. | ||
+ | :SKc> Hard to do it right. | ||
+ | * Nesting ''verse'' tag in ''lg'' tag, suggested by [[User:Yvand|Yvand]] | ||
+ | :In the OSIS file, you can found <code><verse sID="{sID}" osisID="{osisID}" n="{n}"/><l> ... </l><verse eID="{eID}"/></code> which is valid against XML Schema. | ||
+ | :But it is more logical/coherent to put ''verse'' tags in a ''l'' tag. | ||
+ | * Remove useless <code>i</code> tags, suggested by [[User:Yvand|Yvand]] | ||
+ | :The regular expressions <code>s/<\/i>((\s|-|,)+)<i>/\1/g</code>, <code>s/<i>((\s|-|\.|,|;)+)<\/i>/\1/g</code> and <code>s/<i>((\s|-|\.|,|;)+)/\1<i>/g</code> eradicates numerous useless <code>i</code> tags. | ||
+ | * Replace « <code>litt</i>.</code> » by « <code>litt.</i></code> », suggested by [[User:Yvand|Yvand]] | ||
* Use lowercase for chapter titles in Psalms, suggested by [[User:Yvand|Yvand]] corrected in ? | * Use lowercase for chapter titles in Psalms, suggested by [[User:Yvand|Yvand]] corrected in ? | ||
:Currently the chapter titles are <code>Chapter N</code>, except in the Psalms in which it is <code>PSAUME N</code>. | :Currently the chapter titles are <code>Chapter N</code>, except in the Psalms in which it is <code>PSAUME N</code>. |
Latest revision as of 20:30, 15 May 2017
New website : frejnd.yapper.fr
Suggestions, ideas for improvement
- References to notes, reported by Yvand
- Some notes refer to other notes (in another passage), and so uses * (or ** etc.) to refer to a particular notes in a verse.
- Two examples have been noticed, see the note e in Judg.13.19 and in the note in 1Chr.26.18 (** should be replaced by the given note attribute).
- I guess these two particular cases should be corrected manually.
- Move spacing tags from Psalm headers to verse 1 in Psalms, suggested by Yvand
- As in the paper version, my opinion is that spacing tags shouldn't be in Psalms headers but at the beginning of verse 1.
- See for example Ps.3, Ps.9, Ps.16 etc.
- Keep the notes in book and chapter titles, suggested by Yvand
- Currently notes in book titles (Song, Rev are concerned) are moved to a paragraph foregoing the chapter content.
- Those two notes do not preview correctly in Xiphos. David Haslam
- As well, notes in chapter titles (Ps.25, Ps.34, Ps.37, Ps.111, Ps.112, Ps.119, Ps.145, Lam.1 are concerned) are also moved at the beginning of a paragraph below.
- The notes in those Psalm titles preview OK in Xiphos, but the note in Lam 1 does not. David Haslam
Resolved issues
- Wrong note numbering when both standard notes and references notes are present, reported by Yvand
- This issue concerns only some notes in the NT. It appears if a verse mixes standard notes and crossReference notes.
- See Matt.4.10 Heb.3.11 for instance.
- Skc> Hard to fix, as crossReferences are parsed first and then standard notes
- Missing paragraph breaks after (some) clusters/stars , reported by Yvand
- The presence of a cluster in the source involves a new paragraph. But it doesn't work if the cluster does not follow a paragraph of notes.
- Examples for Clustermoyen can be found in Gen.11.27, Gen.25.12.
- Examples for Clustersecondaire can be found in the Psalms, for instance Ps.3.7, Ps.4.2, Ps.5.3, Ps.27, Ps.14.1.
- Missing paragraph break in 1John.2.13 (twice) and in 1John.2.14
- Wrong note ID in the titles of the books Song and Rev, reported by Yvand
- Skc> Still exists? Yes! David Haslam
- Yvand> Yes, the osisRef and osisID attributes still contains the osisID of the previous book (for example for the note in Rev : osisRef="Jude.1.0" osisID="Jude.1.0_1" but n="a")
- Yvand> (I do not know what is best but in my opinion, the alphabetic numeration of notes should start at the beginning of a chapter. So if a note is present in the booktitle (only 2 cases) it shouldn't start the numeration of the chapter. But what value should we use for the n attribute? x? *?)
- Same notes with different n attributes, reported by Yvand
- The issue seems to concern only two verses, these verses contain notes which should use the same n attribute!
- The note d in Zech.5.3 must be c ; as well the note i in Isa.24.16 must be h.
- This is due to a limitation in darbywork.pl which doesn't allow same duplicate note ** or ***, so darby.patch forces to create a new note.
- Use
id
attribute instead ofname
attribute in html files, addhref
attribute ina
tags, suggested by Yvand
- A patch (for
osis2html.xslt
) has been send to the developper.
- Use range verses in osisRef, for continuous verses, suggested by Yvand
- For example
<reference osisRef="Exod.22.26">Exode 22:26</reference>-27
should be replaced by<reference osisRef="Exod.22.26-27">Exode 22:26-27</reference>
in Job.24.9 (note). According to the OSIS Manual, this syntax is valid. - SKc> Hard to do it right.
- Nesting verse tag in lg tag, suggested by Yvand
- In the OSIS file, you can found
<verse sID="{sID}" osisID="{osisID}" n="{n}"/><l> ... </l><verse eID="{eID}"/>
which is valid against XML Schema. - But it is more logical/coherent to put verse tags in a l tag.
- Remove useless
i
tags, suggested by Yvand
- The regular expressions
s/<\/i>((\s|-|,)+)<i>/\1/g
,s/<i>((\s|-|\.|,|;)+)<\/i>/\1/g
ands/<i>((\s|-|\.|,|;)+)/\1<i>/g
eradicates numerous uselessi
tags.
- Replace «
litt</i>.
» by «litt.</i>
», suggested by Yvand - Use lowercase for chapter titles in Psalms, suggested by Yvand corrected in ?
- Currently the chapter titles are
Chapter N
, except in the Psalms in which it isPSAUME N
. - I suggest to replace
PSAUME N
byPsaume N
.
- Double dot in some notes in Psalms, reported by Yvand, corrected in 1.18
- Two dots (instead of a single dot) are present in the last note of the headers of Ps.34, Ps.60, Ps.111, Ps.112.
- The problem seems to occur when there are more than one note in a Psalm header.
- CrossReference notes too greedy, reported by Yvand, corrected in 1.18
- Sometimes it captures other characters (mostly dots) in the note
- See for example Matt.2.6, Matt.2.15, Matt.2.18, Matt.4.10 (about 31 notes concerned) includes the dot of the sentence, as others don't (like Matt.1.23, Matt.3.3)
- The regular expression
s/([0-9]\])( |\.)<\/i>/\1<\/i>\2/g
can solve the problem.
- Gen.49.1 should not be in a poetic group, reported by Yvand corrected in 1.18
- Space problem due to Tidy, reported by Yvand corrected in 1.18
- See for example John.21.5 (twice, after ":" and after "?"), John.18.22, John.18.28, Exod.6.2 (before the parenthesis) etc.
- It appears if a line ends with <i...> or <span...>, tidy doesn't add a space when indenting (although there is a newline)!
- Double dagger symbol (U+2021) in Acts 16:30 reported by David Haslam corrected in 1.17
- Hebrew using "Psaume" instead of "Chapter" reported by Etienne corrected in 1.17
- Typo in Num.33.51 ("paya" instead of "pays") reported by Etienne corrected upstream and in 1.17
- Nested note in Rom.9.33 reported by Yvand corrected in 1.17
- Misplaced alineas (end of previous verse instead of start of next verse) reported by Yvand corrected in 1.17
- Different dates (we can find two different dates : 1859 and 1975, in the .conf file and in the OSIS file (header>work>identifier)) -> See FreJND#About_years
- Update link (replace http://www.bpcbs.com/ by http://www.labonnesemence.com/ in the .conf file) reported by Yvand corrected in 1.17
- Missing letter ID in notes (see Gen.49.5, Num.21.12) reported by Yvand corrected in 1.17
- Remove § in Gen.3.2, Gen.6.2, Gen.7.2, Gen.8.2, etc reported by Yvand corrected in 1.17
- Add § in Gen.10.2, Gen.37.2 (problem with new § on verse 2 not found) reported by Yvand corrected in 1.17
- Wrong chapter titles : in the Psalms the chapter title is "Chapitre #", while in the Epistle to the Hebrews it is "Psaume #" instead of "Chapitre #" reported by Etienne corrected in 1.17
- Typo in Num.33.51 paya instead of pays reported by Etienne corrected in 1.17 (and upstream)